News

Husband jailed for lack of disclosure in divorce case

  • January 17, 2013
  • By Hunters Law

Scot Young has been sentenced to six months in jail for failing to comply with Court Orders requiring him to make financial disclosure in divorce proceedings.

The Young divorce case has been widely reported in the press. Mr Young maintains that he has no assets, having lost everything in a disastrous business venture. His lifestyle, he says, is supported by friends. Mrs Young maintains that her husband has secreted wealth of up to £400 million.

In financial cases on divorce both parties are required to give financial disclosure supported by evidence. Each party may raise questions on the other’s disclosure. Mrs Young did so in July 2008 asking, amongst other things, for evidence of how Mr Young was supporting himself. Numerous orders were made requiring Mr Young to respond; a six month sentence of imprisonment was imposed in June 2009, but suspended to allow Mr Young more time to respond. He failed to do so.

In November 2012, the High Court made a further order requiring that Mr Young respond, and the Judge made clear that further failure to comply may result in a jail term. Mr Young purported to respond, but some responses were described by the Judge as “absurd” and “next to useless”. To commit Mr Young to prison the Judge had to be satisfied “beyond reasonable doubt” that he had failed to comply with the Court’s order to respond, and it was for Mrs Young to show that this was the case. This standard was found to be met.

The aim of the sentence is not to punish Mr Young, but to secure the information. The Judge made clear that if Mr Young now complied, the sentence may be lifted.

Judges will continue to give litigants every opportunity to comply with orders for disclosure before resorting to committal, but the fact that it has been imposed on this occasion, and the publicity it has received, will send a message that the Court is not willing to allow non-disclosers to ignore their obligations without consequence.

Please contact our Family team for advice on this and related issues.

Related News

Apr 09, 2019
Henry Hood comments on the no-fault divorce reform in The Guardian
Apr 05, 2019
Jo Carr-West comments on a £1.3m divorce award despite signing a pre-nuptial agreement in Family Law Week
Apr 04, 2019
Richard Kershaw examines the case of Daga v Bangur and trusts in the Family Division in WealthBriefing
Apr 04, 2019
Rebecca Christie comments on the Civil Partnerships, Marriages and Deaths Act 2019 that came into force in The Times
Mar 07, 2019
Richard Kershaw comments on the case of Cowan v Foreman in New Law Journal
Mar 04, 2019
Richard Kershaw examines the case of Daga v Bangur and trusts in the Family Division in Family Law LexisNexis
Feb 06, 2019
Hazel Wright reaccredited by the Family Mediation Council as a specialist family mediator
Dec 17, 2018
Henry Hood comments on the sale of the £4.5 million helicopter in the Akhmedova divorce case in Family Law Week
Nov 23, 2018
Jay Patel comments on a racing driver’s ex-wife’s possible entitlement to a £5 million divorce settlement in Family Law
Nov 09, 2018
Henry Hood comments on Sharia court ignoring an order from the High Court that an oligarch must hand over a £350m yacht to his ex-wife in The Law Society Gazette and Family Law Week

© Hunters Law LLP 2019 | Privacy NoticeLegal & Regulatory | Cookies Policy | Complaints Procedure

Hunters Law LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (number 657218)