News

Henry Hood’s article re Prest v. Petrodel Resources Ltd and DR v GR & others in UKSC

  • January 15, 2013
  • By Hunters Law

Rorke’s Drift in the Family Division: A Tale of two judgments

Prest (Appellant) v. Petrodel Resources Ltd and Others (Respondent) 2013 UKSC 34 

DR v GR & others (Financial Remedy: Variation of Overseas Trust) 2013 1996 (Fam)

The preservation of the corporate veil, or the ability to achieve fairness for the economically weaker party in a divorce. For years the Family Division has had no doubt which was the more important. The concepts came head to head in two cases earlier this year. It does not seem likely that we have arrived at a final position, but it is instructive to see where things lie at this stage.

To explain the position, Henry Hood first reviews Prest v Petrodel Resources Ltd and particularly the speech of Lord Sumption who sets out the relevant facts and some of the history of the Family Divisions approach to issues concerning the corporate veil. It is no secret that he, as the majority in the Court of Appeal had before him, did not agree with that approach and he arrived at a statement of principle which Lord Justice Thorpe (the dissenter in the Court of Appeal) described as giving to a husband who wished to avoid his obligations “a fast car and an open road” Was the game up?

Those who thought so reckoned without Mostyn J who in DR v GR might have found a way round the difficulty which all of us in operating in the Family Division think we face. However, whether these efforts will survive the attentions of the Higher Courts must be doubtful.

Read the full article, in UKSC via a PDF, here.

Related News

Apr 27, 2021
Eri Horrocks discusses arrangements for divorcing couples with pets during National Pet Month
Apr 26, 2021
Polly Atkins examines whether a former spouse can be required to pay rent pending the sale of the family home in STEP Journal+
Apr 22, 2021
Henry Hood comments on Tatiana Akhmedova winning a High Court lawsuit against son in £450m divorce battle in WealthBriefing
Apr 14, 2021
Jo Carr-West discusses a new approach to domestic abuse in the Family Court
Mar 30, 2021
Eri Horrocks discusses family loans and divorce settlements
Mar 23, 2021
Henry Hood discusses Capitalisation of maintenance and Duxbury Calculations
Mar 17, 2021
Jo Carr-West discusses the capitalisation of child maintenance in Family Law Week
Mar 15, 2021
Eri Horrocks discusses top tips for international families on divorce
Feb 26, 2021
Richard Kershaw considers the implications of Mr Justice Cohen’s judgment in FRB v DRC (No 3) in Family Law Week
Feb 25, 2021
Richard Kershaw examines the impact of market volatility on divorce settlements in Finance Monthly

© Hunters Law LLP 2021 | Privacy NoticeLegal & Regulatory | Cookies Policy | Complaints Procedure.

Hunters Law LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (number 657218)