News

Hazel Wright comments on Tini Owens divorce refusal appeal in Family Law Week

  • February 22, 2017
  • By Hunters Law

The Court of Appeal has heard an appeal by Tini Owens against the refusal of HHJ Tolson QC to grant her a divorce form her husband, Hugh Owens, on the grounds that the marriage had irretrievably broken down by reason of the husband’s irretrievable behaviour. The couple have been married for 39 years. Mr Owens denies that the marriage has broken down.

Hazel Wright, Partner at Hunters, commented:

“This case has of course hit the news headlines. Partly because of the detail and the near obsession of the public with the private details of unhappy lives. But also because of the high profile given, particularly in recent months, to increasing pressure from lawyers (including the most senior judges) for a change in the law, to allow divorce where neither spouse has to make an allegation of fault – the no fault divorce.

“The case is a reflection of the clash of two forces in our society. The one (Mrs Owens) pushes for a recognition of unhappiness and hopelessness. In our society where we are increasingly open about emotions, where couples are encouraged to go to counselling and to mediation not to the court to sort out differences, her plight will be recognised by many. Where judges have discretion, as here, to consider the individuals in question, they should remember that times have changed. Certainly, views on divorce have changed greatly since this couple (she is aged 65, he is aged 78) married in 1978.

“The other viewpoint is that marriage is ‘for better or for worse’. Marriage is sometimes unhappy, and sometimes things go better. It is not enough, in law, for one person just to decide she wants out. Mr Owens does not. He says he has the law on his side. Some other jurisdictions round the world say he is quite right, that the only ground for divorce should be really bad behaviour of the other spouse. There is no law at all for divorce in the Philippines, where marriage really is for life.

“If Mr Owens succeeds in blocking the divorce, it remains to be seen quite what sort of marriage he will have. It seems clear that as soon as she can, Mrs Owens will apply to court for the marriage to be dissolved.”

Judgment has been reserved.

Read the full article in Family Law Week here.

Related News

Sep 15, 2021
Henry Hood recognised in the Citywealth Leaders List Top 100 Private Client Lawyers 2021
Sep 14, 2021
Hunters recognised as one of the 2021 eprivateclient Top Family Law Firms
Sep 06, 2021
Hunters Law shortlisted at the Family Law Awards 2021
Aug 02, 2021
Henry Hood examines the Thwaite jurisdiction where a client seeks adjustment of a financial remedy order in The Review
Jul 29, 2021
Eri Horrocks discusses what happens to the children when separated parents differ on relocating in WealthBriefing
Jul 28, 2021
Eri Horrocks discusses a practical guide to emergency private children cases in The Review
Jul 27, 2021
Eri Horrocks discusses what separated parents wanting to relocate within the UK need to know in Family Law Week
Jul 22, 2021
Hunters’ success in the Chambers HNW 2021 Guide
Jul 12, 2021
Jo Carr-West and Lara Barton discuss recent recommendations that would assist divorcing couples in managing the CGT implications of separating their financial affairs in Family Law Week
Jul 07, 2021
Hunters’ success in the 2021 Spear’s Family Law Index

© Hunters Law LLP 2021 | Privacy NoticeLegal & Regulatory | Cookies Policy | Complaints Procedure.

Hunters Law LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (number 657218)