Gregor Kleinknecht discusses Brexit and financial services in Discover Germany

  • September 26, 2018
  • By Gregor Kleinknecht, Partner

Brexit and financial services

Six months to go. The inevitability of Brexit is now pretty much universally accepted. In a best case scenario, agreement will be reached on the terms on which the UK leaves the EU in time for a no-deal scenario to be avoided. This will be combined with a political declaration as to the future UK-EU relationship, and a transitional period will then be put in place until the end of 2020 to enable some form of  arrangements to be agreed for Britain’s future trading relationship with the EU outside of the internal market and customs union.

Most industry sectors  have  contingency plans more or less in place if they are not already in the process of implement- ing them. There are few sectors, however, where the potential impact of Brexit will be quite as significant, and the implications quite as far reaching, as for financial services. Key issues concern the end of Euro-denominated clearing through the City of London through so-called central counterparties, the loss of passporting rights that currently provide financial institutions with EU wide access to financial markets, the end of free movement for the European employees and managers, on whose expertise the City of London currently depends, the continuity of cross-border contracts with and between financial institutions, and doubts about the legal framework for the cross-border transfer of data between the UK and the EU currently governed by GDPR, to name but a few. Financial institutions have already moved some staff and service lines out of the UK and more are likely to follow. Lloyds of London has set up an operation in Brussels. The European Banking Authority is leaving London f’or Paris.

For the UK, these are by no means theoretical problems: in 2016, financial services contributed some 119 billion GBP to the British economy, half of which was generated in London. Britain has a significant trade surplus with the rest of the world in financial services (some 60 billion GBP in export compared to imports of just about 10 billion GBP) and 44 percent of financial services exports go to the EU.

So how is the UK preparing the financial services sector for Brexit? The European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 envisages that, on the day of Brexit, all existing and directly applicable EU legislation (the so- called ‘acquis communautaire’) will automatically be incorporated into  British law and continue to apply. In the area of financial services, it is difficult to see how this will work in practice, given that EU financial services law relies significantly on regulatory bodies (such as the EBA, ESMA, EIOPA and ECB) which Britain will cease to be a member of at the same time. The withdrawal legislation therefore envisages that the newly nationalised EU law will be adapted where necessary to the new circumstances. In the context of financial services regulation, this will require UK bodies, such as the Financial Conduct Authority, Prudential Regulation Authority and Bank of England, to be given the requisite powers and structures both nationally and for cooperating with their EU and other international counterparts. Little has so far happened in this respect.

The recent and now much debated Chequers proposal provided no comfort to the financial services industry, given that it jettisoned a future reliance on passporting rights before they even reached the negotiating table. Instead, the UK is aiming for regulatory independence from the EU, combined with an expanded equivalence framework, mutual recognition of equivalence, supervisory cooperation and regulatory dialogue. Existing free trade agreements between the EU and third countries, such as Canada, Japan and South Korea make no or only very limited provision for financial services and therefore do not provide a template for closer cooperation, and the EU has so far not been for the idea of including financial services in a possible future free-trade agreement with the UK.

And if there is no deal? The government sought to answer this question with its technical paper Banking, insurance and other financial services if there’s no Brexit deal, published on 23 August 2018. It  proposes inter alia to put in place a temporary permissions regime that will allow EEA firms currently passporting into the UK to continue to do so for a limited time and further proposes to implement a  temporary recognition regime for non-UK central counterparties to ensure continuity of clearing services for UK firms. At the same time, the government recognises that the UK will lose access to the EU financial market infrastructure, including Target 2 and SEPA.

So what are possible outcomes of Brexit to the financial services industry? At present, it looks most likely that the current EU third country regime and equivalence rules will be applied to the UK, combined with a formalised process for bilateral consultation. Let’s hope that a transition period will not only be agreed but also be used effectively to put in place workable solutions for the future of the financial services industry.

This article was published in Discover Germany in the October 2018 issue here on page 79.

Related News

Jan 30, 2023
Stephen Morrall and Sophia Smout examine the new rules on flexible working in People Management
Dec 12, 2022
Stephen Morrall comments on the new flexible working rights in Personnel Today
Oct 18, 2022
Stephen Morrall comments on gig economy rulings challenging pension enrolment in Law360
Sep 20, 2022
Stephen Morrall and Annabelle Woosnam discuss the legal rights for gig economy employees to a pension in People Management
Jul 06, 2022
Stephen Morrall and Annabelle Woosnam discuss pensions in the gig economy, in Employee Benefits
Feb 18, 2022
Gregor Kleinknecht discusses Trademarks, Design Rights and Copyright to Promote Business Growth and Innovation in University of Buckingham Press
Feb 11, 2022
Stephen Morrall comments on what COVID rules means for workers and employers in Mail Online, This is Money, Mail on Sunday, Daily Mail and MSN Money
Jan 14, 2022
Gregor Kleinknecht comments on the General Court clarifying the law on rights of representation before EU courts in Managing IP
Nov 30, 2021
Stephen Morrall and Aman Khokhar explore how employers can best determine worker status in People Management
Nov 17, 2021
Richard Baxter examines whether Brexit creates uncertainty for online software sales agents in Reports Legal

© Hunters Law LLP 2023 | Privacy NoticeLegal & Regulatory | Cookies Policy | Complaints Procedure.

Hunters Law LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (number 657218)