News

“Big Money” divorce on appeal to Supreme Court

  • December 17, 2012
  • By Hunters Law

The disappointed ex-wife of oil tycoon, Michael Prest, has been granted permission to appeal the controversial Court of Appeal decision in Petrodel Resources Ltd & Ors -v- Prest & Ors [2012] EWCA Civ 1395.

The Court of Appeal’s majority (2:1) decision on 26th October 2012 caused huge controversy in the family law world when they ruled that the High Court judge had been “wrong” to “pierce the corporate veil” and to equate the companies owned and controlled by Mr Prest with Mr Prest himself and to regard their assets as his.  The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal brought by the three companies owned and controlled by Mr Prest against the Order requiring them to transfer assets to Mrs Prest. Mrs Prest has now been granted permission to appeal this decision.

The Court of Appeal decision highlights the tension that exists between, on the one hand, the fact that, in company law, a company is a separate legal entity that is entirely distinct from its members and, on the other, the inclination of the Family Division to look behind corporate structures if that is required in the interest of achieving fairness. Given the constitution of the Court of Appeal in this case, it is perhaps unsurprising that the former prevailed.

Lord Justice Thorpe, the only Family Law specialist sitting in the Court of Appeal and who delivered the dissenting judgment, warned that the Family Division judge’s overriding duty to achieve fairness would be defeated if company law allows a wealthy businessman to “hide” his assets in corporate structures. The Court of Appeal judgement can be read in full here.

The appeal will be heard in the Supreme Court on the 5th and 6th March 2013. The Family team at Hunters are eagerly awaiting the Supreme Court judgment and are following all the developments.

 

Related News

Feb 26, 2021
Richard Kershaw considers the implications of Mr Justice Cohen’s judgment in FRB v DRC (No 3) in Family Law Week
Feb 25, 2021
Richard Kershaw examines the impact of market volatility on divorce settlements in Finance Monthly
Feb 24, 2021
Polly Atkins examines whether one can charge an ex-spouse rent whilst waiting for their home to sell
Feb 19, 2021
Richard Kershaw examines whether you can re-open a divorce settlement due to Covid-19 in Edward Fennell’s Legal Diary
Feb 02, 2021
Amy Scollan discusses divorce and luxury assets
Feb 01, 2021
Richard Kershaw discusses recent case where an unmarried couple have been ordered to share investment assets
Jan 18, 2021
Family Mediation Week 2021
Nov 19, 2020
Jay Patel and Polly Atkins examine family law in the lead up to Brexit in Family Law Week
Nov 09, 2020
Richard Kershaw discusses trusts on divorce and their role in financial planning strategies
Nov 05, 2020
Hunters recognised in The Times Best Law Firms 2021

© Hunters Law LLP 2021 | Privacy NoticeLegal & Regulatory | Cookies Policy | Complaints Procedure.

Hunters Law LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (number 657218)