News

ASA rules against exaggerated success rate in “instant win” promotions

  • July 30, 2018
  • By Arash Andalibi-Abadan, Trainee Solicitor

The Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) has ruled that instant win promotions on Highland Spring water bottles and packets of McCain French Fries breached The UK Code of Non-broadcast Advertising, Sales Promotion and Direct Marketing (CAP Code) because the chances of winning a prize were far lower than the promotional material suggested.

Highland Spring bottle labels stated that 10,000 “instant win” prizes could be won. Contestants had to enter their details, bottle batch code and time stamp on a website in order to be entered into the draw. To win, their details would have to match the “moment”, which was a one-second period randomly selected by a computer.

Highland Spring printed short terms and conditions on the back of the labels, but some consumers challenged them as misleading. The ASA found that although the labels stated that not all prizes would be won, there was no information on how the promotion worked or how likely it actually was for a consumer to win a prize.

A similar issue was considered in the McCain case. Unique, random codes were printed on a total of 53,317,540 promotional packs of French fries and a total prize fund of £3,000,000 was available to be won.  This equated to 28,515 prizes or a 0.05% chance of winning. A total of 342,713 promotional pack codes were entered into the instant win promotion, and 159 were awarded prizes – i.e. only 0.56% of the available prizes. In addition, of the prizes won, most were in the lowest value range and only a few higher value prizes were available. The highest prizes were not won.

Both promotional campaigns were found to be misleading and caused unnecessary disappointment for consumers because the mechanisms of winning a prize were not properly explained.  In addition, both were found to have created a significantly exaggerated impression of the likelihood of winning, and the brief statements about chances of success in the terms and conditions were not sufficient.  The lesson is that companies must ensure that their promotional campaigns do not exaggerate consumers’ chances of winning and do not cause them unnecessary disappointment.

Written by Arash Andalibi-Abadan and Cécile de Lagarde

For queries in relation to commercial and business matters, please ask a member of our Business Services team.

Related News

Jan 14, 2022
Gregor Kleinknecht comments on the General Court clarifying the law on rights of representation before EU courts in Managing IP
Nov 30, 2021
Stephen Morrall and Aman Khokhar explore how employers can best determine worker status in People Management
Nov 17, 2021
Richard Baxter examines whether Brexit creates uncertainty for online software sales agents in Reports Legal
Nov 02, 2021
Gregor Kleinknecht and Anastassia Dimmek examine the lessons learned from the cancellation of Banksy trademarks in Lawyer Monthly
Oct 20, 2021
Partner Richard Baxter is attending the FT Live’s The Banking Revolution
Oct 18, 2021
Richard Baxter and Constance Tait discuss considerations for dispute resolution and M&A scenarios
Sep 29, 2021
Richard Baxter outlines lessons for business owners from an abortive company sale and purchase transaction
Sep 22, 2021
Stephen Morrall examines worker status in the gig economy in Economy Standard
Jul 22, 2021
Gregor Kleinknecht and Constance Tait examine the impact on trademark litigation and provide 10 tips on navigating the post-Brexit era in Managing IP
Jul 16, 2021
Gregor Kleinknecht and Anastassia Dimmek examine the growing threat of zombie firms in Lawyer Monthly

© Hunters Law LLP 2022 | Privacy NoticeLegal & Regulatory | Cookies Policy | Complaints Procedure.

Hunters Law LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (number 657218)